The way it works, everyone likes the first record better. You’re a music fan, presumably, so you probably understand the idea here that, when placed in historical context, a band’s initial statement to the world is often seen as its most lasting. Motion City Soundtrack began in Minneapolis in 1999. Two years ago, they released their first album, I Am The Movie, crawled inside a van for seemingly the end of eternity and shot a video with their friends back home for “The Future Freaks Me Out,” a loud and instantly enjoyable anthem that has become such an undeniable apex at the band’s live shows that it is no longer sung by singer/guitarist Justin Pierre as much as it is sung back at him.

But as ubiquitous as it became, the song perfectly captured Motion City’s allure. Irresistible and unhinged, “The Future Freaks Me Out” was a reference point for what was to come with Commit This To Memory, ironic considering they wrote the song in mere hours and it almost didn’t even make it onto their debut. “Two weeks before we went in, [guitarist Joshua Cain] played the part and I sang those words and that’s what came out,” Pierre says now in amazement. “It was completely random. But that’s how we work. It’s funny when there’s talk about how this record could ‘make or break us.’” He laughs. “This band has always gone on its gut instinct.”

Last year, by way of the unrelenting schedule they kept behind I Am The Movie, the band was asked to join Blink-182 on a tour of Europe and, then, Japan. Somewhere backstage and in between, bassist Mark Hoppus modestly mentioned to the group that he was interested in pursuing production work once Blink took a necessary pause later in the year. Though he didn’t know it at the time, Hoppus had just found his first client. “We thought of it almost as a joke,’” Cain recalls. "But on our last day of tour I asked him, point blank, ‘Do you want to produce our record?’ When he said, “Fuck yeah” I was like, ’Okay